These adorable Little Fishy Cupcakes are easy and fun and will be a hit with the kids and you just need frosting and some M&M’s to make them.

Closeup on a blue Little Fishy Cupcake sitting on a blue surface.

Laurie and I really set the bar high when we gave Allison’s preschool teacher the Crayon Candy Dish. She still gushes about it when we see her, so when we were talking about bringing cupcakes to Allison’s class for her birthday we wanted to make sure we didn’t disappoint.  Laurie and I were knee-deep in planning the Frozen birthday party extravaganza, so I wanted to do something cute and easy.  These fish cupcakes fit the bill.  All the kids (and the teachers) loved them.

Make a Batch of Cupcakes

A dozen vanilla cupcakes sitting on a white table in front of a cupcake tin and a black and white towel.

Step 1: Make a batch of cupcakes.  You can use a cake box mix, we have all the instructions you’ll need to make them taste just like homemade right here. Or you can make them from scratch with our yummy Homemade Vanilla Cupcakes recipe.  We used vanilla cupcakes but Chocolate Cupcakes would taste great too.

Make the Frosting

Clear mixing bowl filled with homemade buttercream frosting sitting next to a decorating bag filled with buttercream frosting.

Step 2: The key to these delicious cupcakes is our Best Buttercream Frosting recipe.   It is light and creamy and buttery and super delicious! You will find the recipe and directions here.  One batch of frosting will be enough to frost 18 cupcakes. 

Grab Your M&M’s

M&M's arranged in a rainbow pattern on a white surface.

Step 3:  Next, separate the M&M’s by color.  This was from a large bag of M&M’s. You’ll need about 15 M&M’s for the scales for each cupcake and 2 reds for the fish lips.

Color the Frosting

Collage image showing the food coloring formulas for making blue, green, yellow and pink frosting.

Step 4:  Now it is time to tint the frosting. We like the Wilton Color Right Food Coloring.  It is concentrated and you can get a bright color without having to use too much food coloring. We split the frosting into four equal parts, added food coloring, and made yellow, blue, green, and pink frosting.  

Blue:  2 drops of blue food coloring
Green: 3 drops of yellow food coloring and 1 drop of green food coloring
Yellow: 3 drops of yellow food coloring and 1 drop of orange food coloring
Pink: 2 drops of pink food coloring

How to Create a Little Fishy Cupcakes

Collage image showing how to turn a cupcake into a fish using M&M's.

Step 5:  Use a knife or an offset spatula to frost the cupcake.
Step 6: Start with a row of “fish scales” in the middle of the cupcake.  Our cupcakes had enough room for 6 yellow M&M’s. Continue adding rows until you fill up half of the cupcake with M&M fish scales.
Step 7:  We used Wilton Candy Eyes for the fisheye but you could also use a mini marshmallow and a dot of black icing.
Step 8:  Finally, add two red M&M’s for the fish lips. 

Color Options

Overhead shot of a twenty Little Fishy Cupcakes in a variety of colors sitting on a blue surface.

Step 9:  So cute and so very easy to make! And so many color options.  We also made some Rainbow Fish Cupcakes by using two colors of M&M’s for the scales instead of one – same technique but a much different look. That’s it!  It’s really very easy to make these Little Fishy Cupcakes.  This is our favorite kind of project … small time investment but high impact!!!

Eight Little Fishy Cupcakes arranged in a circle on a blue surface.

Other Cupcakes Recipes You Will Love

Did you Make This Recipe? Leave a review below, then snap a picture and tag @twosisterscrafting on Instagram so we can see it!

And don’t forget to follow us on PinterestFacebook, and Instagram!

Little Fishy Cupcakes

Yield 18 cupcakes
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Additional Time 15 minutes
Total Time 45 minutes

These adorable Little Fishy Cupcakes are easy and fun and will be a hit with the kids and you just need frosting and some M&M's to make them.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. First, make a batch of cupcakes.
  2. Next separate the M&M's by color. You'll need about 15 M&M's for the scales for each cupcake, and 2 reds for the fish lips.
  3. Make a batch of our delicious Buttercream Frosting and tint the frosting the colors you want your Little Fishy Cupcake to be.
  4. Frost the cupcakes.
  5. Start with a row of "fish scales" M&M's in the middle of the cupcake. Our cupcakes had enough room for 6 yellow M&M's.
  6. Continue adding rows until you fill up half of the cupcake with M&M fish scales.
  7. Used a Wilton Candy Eyes for the fish eye.
  8. Add two red M&M's for the fish lips.

Did you Make this Recipe? Leave a review below, then snap a picture and tag @twosisterscrafting on Instagram so we can see it!